“I did undoubtedly consider video games naturally inferior to film and literature. Over there is a structural reason for that: video games by your nature require player choices, i m sorry is the opposite of the strategy of serious film and literature, which calls for authorial control”.

You are watching: Do you feel like a hero yet?

Ebert’s skepticism towards video clip games as a “high art” was not an unpopular opinion when he created this in 2005. However, he to be short-sighted in the way user interactivity might tell stories a new way. Spec Ops: The line puts its system and also gameplay right into a continual fight with the game’s rigid to produce a ludonarrative dissonance, conflict between the gameplay and narrative that a game, the critiques the player and also the state the the modern shooter. The game uses the input of the players and a concentrated narrative to create an artistic experience that exceeds Ebert’s idea of video game inferiority.

Spec Ops: The Line tells the story the the player together Captain martin Walker, in addition to his squadmates sublievenant Adams and Sergeant Lugo, together they travel v a damaged Dubai trying to find Colonel john Konrad, lacking commander the the 33rd Battalion. After committing atrocious acts, Walker develops dissociative disorder come cope through his actions together he falls further into insanity. The ludic elements,which space the video game mechanics, perform not reflect Walker’s illness. Instead, the video game has the feeling of a standard modern-day shooter, permitting the player come aim, take it cover, pick up guns, litter grenades, and command squadmates. It additionally starts with the generally used backdrop of a foreign city, utilizing generic Middle-Eastern adversaries as targets. The game does not excel in any of this areas, presenting no brand-new mechanics for the player come use and at first appears come stick come the overused formula of current shooter narratives.

Once the pat progresses more into the story, the becomes noticeable that the trivial ludic and background aspects early on room meant to make the player feeling comfortable with the game. As the player starts to go atrocities in ~ the game, the player’s actions comparison the narrative and also create a ludonarrative dissonance. In one section, an angry mob forms about Walker after ~ the lynching the a teammate. They are throwing rocks at the player i beg your pardon hurt but will no kill Walker. Your character pulls the end his gun throughout this sequence, i m sorry is a telltale authorize in modern shooters that a fight is beginning. The player is not given instructions come fire, however the rule of modern-day shooting games dictate the the player go in this situation. What the player doesn’t know that if lock shoot right into the air, the mob would certainly disperse without bloodshed. Yet by containing the ludic aspects of other gamings in the genre, players feeling inclined come commit fixed violence when in reality the video game is letting the player pick for pedestrian without fully expressing so.



Walker’s find for Konrad appears as the usual heroism seen in games like speak to of Duty, Medal of Honor, and also other war games where the main character has to slaughter many enemies to end up being the victor. The purity of walker is sustained until the white phosphorous section of the game. Walker and also his team find the base of an adversary group in Dubai. Together they sneak right into the facility, they discover an abandoned mortar with white phosphorus, a deadly weapon of chemistry warfare, in it. The player is forced to fire it in ~ the adversary units, who appear as white dots on Walker’s radar, a clever means by the video game makers come dehumanize the world being slaughtered. The player goes to investigate the remains of the chemistry bombing, and also find that noncombatant civilians were also killed. A maimed soldier tells walker that your intention was to relocate the civilians come safety. This is crucial moment, together it is the clean break native an in-synch narrative and also ludic come a ludonarrative dissonance that specifies the rest of the video game. From below on out, the video game is advertise the player come commit atrocities v gameplay and also objectives if in the stare punishing pedestrian for his chemical massacre of innocents.

The start of the ludonarrative dissonance additionally coincides with Walker’s dissociative disorder, bring about himself and the player to think that Konrad is still alive and also speaking to them over the radio. Konrad starts harshly criticizing pedestrian for his actions, also though the player is complying with the rules and game mechanics the never readjusted since the beginning of the game. Opponents are still created for walker to shoot, and also the player proceeds to reason harm come Dubai in the method the video game says to. For example, in one section Walker is instructed to wipe the end the city’s remaining water supply to continue through the game. The ludic elements do not give the player a way to continue the game and avoid the section, however the stare is advertise the player to not make destructive decisions.



As the consistent battle between the ludic and also the narrative forces the player come commit much more atrocities, the game begins to phone call the player much more directly the their actions room dishonorable. Spec Ops: The Line offers the loading screen for this, a place developed in previous gamings to learn more about the story or check out information around controls, come directly slam the player. Phrases such as “Do girlfriend feel favor a hero yet?” and also “If you to be a much better person, you i will not ~ be here” taunt the player for proceeding to pat the game. The narrative desires the player to prevent playing, however the ludic facets never force them to quit. Missions still appear, and also enemies quiet spawn. Once the player reaches the end of the game, they uncover out the Konrad has been dead the totality time. Walker was convincing self to commit this atrocities, and also used Konrad to justify it. Spec Ops: The Line parallels this with the player, by mentioning that choose Walker, the player is the one who decided to cause the devastation by taking orders from someone that isn’t real. This is the high point of the dissonance, where the player complied with the game’s orders and also objectives regardless of a stare that just wanted castle to collection the controller down and quit playing. Contradictory to what all video clip game players have been taught, the only winning move is not to play.

See more: Photograph: Fedor Jeftichew ( Jo Jo The Dog Faced Boy, Pin On Mutants

The ludonarrative dissonance of Spec Ops: The Line usesthe game’s ludic elements of thoughtless destruction and also the rigid idea the justifying fear to heroism to create a game that pushes the player to proceed playing also though lock will never reach a solve “You Win” screen. Contradictory to Ebert’s opinion, the game would have never been able to do its allude to players without offering them the flexibility to fail. The liberty to permit the player to take on expected heroism shown by the ludic aspects lets the stare succeed together a counterpoint to war shooters and also the player’s apathy to the genre’s violence.